15 Comments
User's avatar
Lotus's avatar

great conversation!

of all of king’s numerous contributions to watch discourse, the most remarkable is how he got people like tony and brandon (on sjx) to address him by his nom de plume on their podcasts.

i hope the day comes soon when clymer is addressing his flumness on hodinkee 🤣

Tony Traina's avatar

haha i only slipped once!

Rick's avatar

Tony, I really enjoyed the convo with King Flum. Along with Unpolished, SDC is one of my favorite reads.

And, I applaud you for honest reviews and feedback. Who cares if a brand un-invites you to release parties and events. The watch world needs more critical analysis and less watch media regurgitating the same old brand-based press releases. A significant reason behind the growth of Substack/Patreon paid watch platforms is the need to differentiate from Monochrome, Hodinkee, Fratello etc.

Keep it up, we are loving the unbiased approach in Unpolished.

Tony Traina's avatar

Thanks for listening and reading Rick. And yes, I’d much rather write / say what I want than go to some party anyway :)

Andy Wong's avatar

What a great episode! My two favorite substacks together in one podcast really showing the commonalities and differences that make these both unique but essential perspectives. Brands and media get better all the time at selling the new shiny thing and people, consumers, need both real scholarship and developed personal philosophy just to keep up in the battle for their minds and wallets. Unpolished and SDC are exactly what we need even if we dont know it.

Charles Thayer's avatar

Let me echo the prior commenters’ praise. Getting back to the title of the piece - On the mission, Victor Glover, Artemis II astronaut, brought a recently purchased Speedmaster. In fact, all the astronauts brought non-issued Speedmasters. Christina Koch brought her dad’s. It would be fascinating to understand the inner motivations of why these gifted scientists needed these in support of their personal missions.

Larry S's avatar

TT and KF, what a dream team for me! I would have been over the moon if you two decided to do an "Acquired" length pod. It took me two listenings to get the depth of the conversation (especially once you two got "warmed up"). You are absolutely right on Watch Mental Health (OK to enjoy without ownership), Community/Cult (WA is nice, but in-person is much nicer) and uncensored critique. At least going back to Forum days, there was free speech as long as you weren't an asshole, but group think was not as prevalent as it is today, which I think is an outcome of so much info available at a finger's touch so with 3 or 4 clicks, lots of "collectors" consider themselves experts. And we all know the definition of expert. Now in the mid -'20s, we absorb the discourse of analytical writers like you two, who don't need a press release and can talk candidly the big picture. As we approach the madness of Geneva Watch Fairs, for the second year, I'm willing to stand back and absorb what is going on (well, last year was an all-time doozy!) and not be pestering ADs to be first on the list for whatever the latest and greatest everyone is shouting about.

Patrick S's avatar

Kingflum, Tony Traina, and Velociphile—that’s my Substack Holy Trinity.

kingflum's avatar

I like that you went with alphabetical order so you don't need to 'rank' anything - genius, really. 🤓😂

Judah Rosenthal's avatar

How many other “voices” in what’s becoming mainstream watch media have truly managed to do it without a stint with “legacy” watch media? It’s really interesting to read and hear their thoughts. I love fawning reviews but also like the more analytical approach that doesn’t rely on maintaining access to sustain itself.

Tony Traina's avatar

This is of course something I thought about a lot when I was deciding whether to join Hodinkee or not. There’s no doubt in my mind it fast-forwarded my ‘development’ by 2x. There are many virtues of independent media but it also means there’s a lot of noise and perhaps the best way to establish yourself is to spend time at a “mainstream” publication. I compare it to an elite university. We can quibble about the value of the in-classroom education but that is a very small part of the overall experience.

Judah Rosenthal's avatar

I love Hodinkee. Who doesn’t love a hype man?

Scott Tarlow's avatar

Really enjoyed this episode.

re: China coming for the swiss. I think one of the biggest hills they will have to climb (and why Japan Indies have done so well) is that many European countries are "known" to make luxury / status symbols and people fetishize their culture. That does a lot not just for watches, but also fashion houses and other luxury products. Japan has the same effect. USA has this in some respects too - and a lot of that is because of the post war good will they built all around the world. China's brand isn't Russia bad, but its not great. They sell stuff because of price - but at the same price - people would prefer something thats worse from a different country.

China needs to do global institution building to really start selling premium products the way that Europe and Japan do IMO. There is still a lot of negative sentiment towards China here in the west - I can see that changing - but they have very different philosophies on how to live.